The Sandpapergate controversy has returned to the spotlight following fresh claims in Usman Khawaja’s autobiography, Sabr. The Australian batter alleged that the entire team knew about the 2018 ball-tampering incident. Captain Pat Cummins strongly rejected the claims during a 68-minute press conference on November 13, 2026. He called Khawaja’s allegations utter nonsense and insisted that he was 100 per cent wrong. Former Australia opener Matthew Hayden has now criticised Cummins’ response. He believes the captain’s comments could create further problems when Australia travels to India for the Border-Gavaskar Trophy.
Matthew Hayden Questions Pat Cummins’ Handling Of Sandpapergate Controversy
Cummins addressed several questions about the controversy and also spoke about his friendship with Khawaja. He suggested that friends should not treat each other’s lives and reputations casually.
Hayden was not impressed with the captain’s approach. He believes Cummins made the disagreement more personal by bringing their friendship into the discussion.
“Pat Cummins has come out and basically thrown Usman under the bus. He’s raised very personal issues regarding their friendship and how casually he believes that friendship has been treated,” Hayden told JioStar.
The former Australian batter also questioned Cummins’ decision to put a time limit on questions about Sandpapergate. The captain reportedly indicated that he would answer questions for around 90 minutes before refusing to discuss the matter further.
Hayden believes this approach will not work, particularly during Australia’s upcoming India tour.
“He’s gone on record saying, ‘I’ll answer questions for an hour and a half, but after this, I’m not answering any more questions about it.’ That basically means that when Australia travels to India for the Border-Gavaskar Trophy, he won’t want to answer questions about Sandpapergate, which is wishful thinking at best,” Hayden said.
Hayden also warned that the controversy could become a major talking point inside the Australian dressing room. Opposition players could use the issue to put pressure on Cummins and his teammates during important matches.
“This is a major pressure point within the Australian dressing room. If you wanted to get under Australia’s skin, you would keep raising this issue because there will immediately be a reaction,” Hayden said.
With the controversy still attracting attention, Cummins could face more questions during the India tour. Hayden believes avoiding the subject may only bring further attention to the issue.


